Workday Learning: what it does for training evaluation and what an LMS does not measure
Which tools Workday Learning offers for evaluating training, where the limits are and how to measure transfer effectiveness alongside Workday.
Many companies that run their HR processes in Workday also use Workday Learning. The learning module is part of the Workday platform and connects courses, content and mandatory training with HR data: courses can be assigned by role or area, completions appear in the employee profile, and reports draw on the same data as the rest of HR.
For managing learning, that is strong. Whether a training works is a question it does not answer by itself. This post shows what Workday Learning offers for training evaluation, where a gap remains and how to close it.
Training evaluation in Workday Learning
For learner feedback, Workday Learning uses surveys. According to the Workday documentation, they are used only to gather feedback and are added to a course as a lesson of their own, in digital as well as blended courses (Workday, n.d.). The stated aim is to continuously improve content based on that feedback.
Viewed through Kirkpatrick's four level model (1959), it looks like this:
After the training
- Level 4ResultsWhat does the training bring the organization?
- Level 3BehaviorThis is where the value is decidedDo participants apply what they learned? This needs its own questions and the right timing.
In the training
- Level 2LearningWhat have participants learned? Often through tests in embedded learning content.
- Level 1ReactionWhere most companies measureHow did participants like the training? In Workday through a survey lesson in the course.
So the tools for feedback are there. How meaningful they become depends on which questions you ask and when. The post The Kirkpatrick model: training evaluation in four levels explains the levels in detail.
Where the gap lies
An LMS is built to organize learning. Measuring transfer is a toolkit there, not a ready metric. That applies to Workday Learning just as much as to other suites such as SAP SuccessFactors or Cornerstone. In practice, three gaps show up:
- You define the questions yourself. Surveys often end up with the questions of the classic feedback form: how satisfied were you? But satisfaction is hardly related to later behavior at work (Alliger & Janak, 1989; Alliger et al., 1997). A metric that makes courses and providers comparable is something you first have to develop yourself.
- Feedback is not impact. Workday itself describes surveys as a tool for improving content. Whether what was learned arrives at work is a different question and needs different questions.
- External trainings stay outside. Many trainings are run by external trainers and training providers. They usually have no access to their clients' Workday and can neither measure nor prove their effectiveness there.
Which questions reveal more about transfer than satisfaction questions is shown in the post Feedback forms for seminars and training.
Using Workday Learning and PMScore together
PMScore does not replace an LMS. Courses, assignments and completions stay in Workday. PMScore adds the metric that is missing there: the Transfer Effectiveness Score (TES). At the end of the course, participants answer a short, anonymous assessment, via link or QR code, without an account and without access to Workday. It asks about what matters for transfer:
Competence gain
How much have participants learned?
Ability to apply
Do they feel able to use what they learned in their own work?
Transfer intention
Do they actually intend to put it into practice?
Together they make up the TES from 0 to 100. The values in the example are made up. Because every assessment yields the same TES, you compare courses, formats and providers directly, including trainings by external providers that never appear in Workday. Where a value drops, PMScore asks why.
The TES is based on participants' self assessment. It does not replace observation at work, but it makes transfer effectiveness measurable in every course with little effort. How to build such metrics into your reporting is shown in the post Training controlling: steering learning and development with metrics that show transfer.
What to take away
- Use Workday Learning for what it is built for: assigning courses, providing content, recording completions.
- Check which questions your surveys ask. Satisfaction says little about transfer.
- Add a metric for transfer effectiveness that is the same in every course and covers external trainings too.
How other suites handle the topic is shown in the post SAP SuccessFactors Learning: training evaluation and transfer. What an LMS can do in general is covered in the post Learning management system (LMS) and learning impact.
Use the TES next to Workday?
Tell us which trainings you manage today in Workday Learning or another LMS. In a short conversation we show you how the TES runs alongside it and what you can report from it.
Sources
- Alliger, G. M., & Janak, E. A. (1989). Kirkpatrick's levels of training criteria: Thirty years later. Personnel Psychology, 42(2), 331-342.
- Alliger, G. M., Tannenbaum, S. I., Bennett, W., Jr., Traver, H., & Shotland, A. (1997). A meta-analysis of the relations among training criteria. Personnel Psychology, 50(2), 341-358.
- Kirkpatrick, D. L. (1959). Techniques for evaluating training programs. Journal of the American Society of Training Directors, 13(11), 3-9.
- Workday (n.d.). Setup Considerations: Learning Lessons. Workday Administrator Guide. doc.workday.com
Workday is a trademark of Workday, Inc. This post is independent and not affiliated with Workday.