Skip to content
PMScore Logo
BlogKnowledge

Alternatives to SAP SuccessFactors Learning: which solution measures whether training works?

LMS suites, evaluation software or transfer measurement: an objective overview of what the alternatives to SuccessFactors Learning offer for training evaluation and which question to settle before you choose.

Anyone looking for alternatives to SAP SuccessFactors Learning usually has one of two problems. Either the learning management system (LMS) itself does not fit: too expensive, too complex, too much functionality for the size of the organization. Or the LMS runs fine, but nobody can say whether the trainings work.

In the first case you are looking for another LMS. In the second case switching helps little, because the gap is not in the system but in the measurement. This post sorts the alternatives into three groups and shows which group fits which problem.

LMS suites: Cornerstone and Workday Learning

The obvious alternative to SuccessFactors Learning is another LMS. Cornerstone and Workday Learning are two widely used suites for larger organizations. Both come with evaluation tools:

  • Cornerstone structures course evaluation along the first three Kirkpatrick levels: reaction, knowledge and behavior. For level 3 you define who evaluates, for example the participants themselves or their manager, and how many days after completion the evaluation becomes available (Wisconsin DPM, 2026).
  • Workday Learning adds surveys as a lesson in a course to gather feedback on a course, an offering or a lesson (Workday, n.d.-a). Surveys are not graded there, you cannot assign a correct answer (Workday, n.d.-b).

The pattern is the same as in SuccessFactors Learning, which also covers levels 1 to 3 through surveys and assessments (SAP, n.d.). In all three systems you put the questions together yourself, and level 3 comes weeks or months after the course. Switching LMS just for evaluation therefore swaps one tool for a similar one. Why that falls short for transfer is explained in the post SAP SuccessFactors Learning: what it does for training evaluation and where the gap lies.

Evaluation software: evasys and evalea

The second group does not replace the LMS but adds professional evaluation to it:

  • evasys is software for online and paper questionnaires, used among other things for course evaluations at universities and for training feedback in companies (evasys, n.d.).
  • evalea is a platform for personnel development with eight modules, including seminar management and an evaluation module that evalea describes as digital training controlling (evalea, n.d.).

Such tools are strong when you want to design questionnaires freely and run many evaluations efficiently. Which questions are asked and which metric ends up in the report, however, is again up to you. If they contain the usual satisfaction questions, the result says little about transfer: two meta analyses show that satisfaction is not related to later behavior at work (Alliger & Janak, 1989; Alliger et al., 1997).

Transfer measurement: PMScore alongside any LMS

PMScore is neither an LMS nor general questionnaire software. It measures one thing: how effective a training is at transfer. At the end of the course, participants answer a short, anonymous assessment, via link or QR code, without an account. From it comes the Transfer Effectiveness Score (TES) from 0 to 100, built from competence gain, ability to apply and transfer intention.

Because the questions are the same in every course, trainings become comparable, even across system boundaries: an internal training from the LMS and a seminar by an external provider who never had access to your LMS.

The values in the example are made up. They show what a comparison reveals: in the external seminar participants learn quite a bit, but feel much less able to apply it. Where the value drops, PMScore asks why. The result is there at the end of the course, not months later.

Courses, assignments and certificates stay in SuccessFactors, Cornerstone, Workday or another LMS. PMScore runs alongside. The TES is based on participants' self assessment and does not replace observation at work, but it makes transfer effectiveness measurable in every course with little effort.

How to find the right alternative

Four questions settle which group you need:

  1. Is the LMS itself the problem? If administration, cost or usability do not fit, compare LMS suites. Switching alone does not solve evaluation. What to look for is covered in the post Learning management system (LMS): what it does and why it does not prove learning impact.
  2. Do you need freely designed questionnaires in large numbers? Then evaluation software fits. Plan time to develop good transfer questions.
  3. Do you want to know whether trainings work, the same way in every course? Then you need a fixed metric for transfer effectiveness that runs alongside your LMS.
  4. Do you work with external providers? Then measurement has to work without access to the LMS, otherwise those trainings stay invisible.

More on metrics that show transfer in the post Training controlling: steering learning and development with metrics that show transfer.

Measure transfer without switching your LMS?

Tell us which LMS you use and which trainings you want to evaluate. In a short conversation we show you how the TES runs alongside it.

Thanks! We'll get back to you soon.

That didn't work right now. Please try again later or email us directly.

Sources

  • Alliger, G. M., & Janak, E. A. (1989). Kirkpatrick's levels of training criteria: Thirty years later. Personnel Psychology, 42(2), 331-342.
  • Alliger, G. M., Tannenbaum, S. I., Bennett, W., Jr., Traver, H., & Shotland, A. (1997). A meta-analysis of the relations among training criteria. Personnel Psychology, 50(2), 341-358.
  • evalea (n.d.). Home page. evalea.de
  • evasys (n.d.). Home page. evasys.de
  • SAP (n.d.). Introducing Training Surveys. SAP SuccessFactors Learning Academy. learning.sap.com
  • Wisconsin Department of Personnel Management (2026). Create Evaluations (Cornerstone Job Aid). dpm.wi.gov
  • Workday (n.d.-a). Create Learning Courses. Administrator Guide. doc.workday.com
  • Workday (n.d.-b). Setup Considerations: Learning Lessons. Administrator Guide. doc.workday.com

SAP, SAP SuccessFactors, Cornerstone, Workday, evasys and evalea are trademarks of their respective owners. This post is independent and not affiliated with these companies. Information on third-party products is based on the sources listed, as of November 2026.