Skip to content
PMScore Logo
BlogKnowledge

Skills matrix: structure, levels and how to prove training effectiveness

What a skills matrix (qualification matrix) is, how to build one, what ISO 9001 requires and why a tick next to "trained" does not yet show that the training worked.

Who may operate the new machine? Who can onboard a new colleague? Where is there a gap when two people are on holiday at the same time? A skills matrix answers such questions at a glance. In production, laboratories, service and wherever a quality management system under ISO 9001 is in place, it is part of everyday work.

This post shows how a skills matrix is structured, how to create one in five steps and how to solve the point where many matrices get stuck: proving that a training actually worked.

What is a skills matrix?

A skills matrix is a table: the rows list employees, the columns list the qualifications that matter for their work, such as machines, procedures, test methods or software. Each cell shows the level at which someone masters a qualification.

Common terms also include qualification matrix, training matrix or competency matrix. A competency matrix often takes a broader view and covers methodological and social competencies such as communication or leadership alongside technical ones. The principle is the same.

The levels of a skills matrix

Many companies work with four levels. The exact number matters less than a clear description of how to recognize each level:

Qualified

  1. Level 3Can instruct othersMasters the task confidently and can onboard and train others.
  2. Level 2Works independentlyTarget for most rolesPerforms the task without support at the required quality.

In qualification

  1. Level 1Works under guidancePerforms the task with support or under supervision.
  2. Level 0Not qualifiedHas not yet learned the task and may not perform it alone.

Creating a skills matrix in five steps

  1. Define requirements per role: which tasks belong to which role, and at which level must they be mastered? This gives you the target state.
  2. Describe qualifications and levels: a short description for each column, a recognizable criterion for each level, for example "has completed three changeovers without help".
  3. Capture the current state: together with managers, by observation or testing rather than estimation wherever possible.
  4. Turn gaps into actions: where target and current state differ, onboarding, training or coaching follows, with a date and an owner.
  5. Update regularly: after every action, when machines or procedures change, and at least once a year.

A spreadsheet is enough to start with. Organizations with many sites or roles often use their learning management system or HR software.

Skills matrix and ISO 9001

ISO 9001 does not prescribe a skills matrix. But in clause 7.2 it requires an organization to (ISO 9001:2015):

  • determine the necessary competence of persons whose work affects quality,
  • ensure that these persons are competent on the basis of education, training or experience,
  • where applicable, take actions to acquire the necessary competence and evaluate the effectiveness of the actions taken,
  • retain documented information as evidence of competence.

The skills matrix is the most common way to evidence the first two points and the last one. On the third point, effectiveness, many audits find little.

From "trained" to "effective"

In many matrices, a cell moves up a level as soon as someone has attended a training. But attendance is not evidence of competence. Whether someone can apply what they learned, and does, only shows afterwards. Proven ways to evaluate effectiveness:

  • Practical test or observation at the workplace, especially for safety relevant tasks.
  • Conversation with the manager a few weeks after the training, with a recorded outcome.
  • Standardized assessment at the end of the course for all participants, so that every training is evaluated with the same questions.

PMScore exists for the third way. At the end of the course, participants answer a short, anonymous assessment, and PMScore combines the answers into three components:

  1. Competence gain

    How much have participants learned?

  2. Ability to apply

    Do they feel able to use what they learned in their own work?

  3. Transfer intention

    Do they actually intend to put it into practice?

Together they make up the Transfer Effectiveness Score (TES) from 0 to 100, formed by the same rules for every training. That gives you a documented effectiveness value for every action, which you can compare across trainings, trainers and providers.

The TES is based on participants' self assessment. Where a task is safety relevant, it does not replace a practical test, but complements it. How to build such metrics into your reporting is shown in the post Training controlling: steering learning and development with metrics that show transfer.

What to take away

  1. Describe each level of your skills matrix with a recognizable criterion.
  2. Derive concrete actions with dates from the gaps between target and current state.
  3. Do not move a cell up a level based on attendance alone.
  4. Evaluate the effectiveness of every training with the same method, so the evidence holds up in an audit.

Prove the effectiveness of your training?

Tell us how you document qualifications and training today. In a short conversation we show you how the TES gives you a comparable effectiveness value for every training.

Thanks! We'll get back to you soon.

That didn't work right now. Please try again later or email us directly.

Sources

  • ISO 9001:2015. Quality management systems: Requirements. Clause 7.2 Competence. Geneva: International Organization for Standardization.