The 70-20-10 model: origins, criticism and what it means for training
Where the numbers 70, 20 and 10 come from, how robust they are and why formal training does not become unimportant in the model, but has to set transfer in motion.
Hardly any model is quoted in learning and development as often as 70-20-10. It appears in strategy papers, on conference slides and in budget meetings. Sometimes as an invitation to take learning on the job more seriously, sometimes as an argument for cutting seminars.
This post explains what the model says, where the numbers come from, what critics object and what role formal training actually plays in it.
What the 70-20-10 model says
The model divides workplace learning into three sources:
- Experience: learning through challenging assignments, new responsibility and problem solving in everyday work.
- Other people: learning through feedback, mentoring, coaching and the example of managers and colleagues.
- Formal training: learning in seminars, trainings, courses and e-learning.
Sources of workplace learning in the 70-20-10 model
- Experience at work70 %
- Learning from other people20 %
- Formal training10 %
The message is catchy: most learning does not happen in the seminar room, but at work. Anyone who wants to develop competence should therefore plan not only courses, but also assignments, feedback and support.
Where the numbers come from
The roots lie in research at the Center for Creative Leadership in the 1980s. Morgan McCall, Michael Lombardo and Ann Morrison asked successful executives which experiences had shaped their development most (McCall et al., 1988). They mostly named tough assignments, formative bosses and crises, and seldom seminars.
Michael Lombardo and Robert Eichinger put the well known split into words a few years later in a planning handbook for leadership development (Lombardo & Eichinger, 1996). So the numbers are not measured shares of learning, but a rule of thumb derived from executives' memories of their most important learning experiences.
What critics object
Research has become increasingly critical of the model. A review of the literature concludes that there is hardly any empirical evidence for the specific shares (Clardy, 2018). The main objections:
- The numbers are not measured. They are based on self reports from one particular group, executives, and cannot be transferred to all professions and roles.
- The sources cannot be separated. Someone who tries out a new method in a project after a seminar and gets feedback on it learns from all three sources at once.
- The model is misused. Concluding that seminars only matter ten percent means cutting the budget where the impulse for learning on the job often comes from.
As a reminder that learning does not end with the seminar, the model remains useful. As a formula for budgets, it is not.
What this means for formal training
Read carefully, the model does not devalue formal training, but gives it a clear job: it should set the 70 and the 20 in motion. A seminar after which nobody does anything differently has missed that job, no matter how well it was rated.
Baldwin and Ford (1988) already showed that transfer depends strongly on the work environment: on the opportunity to apply what was learned and on support from managers and colleagues. A training in the spirit of 70-20-10 therefore plans beyond the seminar room:
- Transfer tasks for the first weeks that translate what was learned into real work (the 70).
- Conversations with the manager before and after the training, learning partnerships among participants (the 20).
- Practical content and exercises with examples from participants' own work (the 10, done well).
Measuring whether training sets transfer in motion
Whether a training builds the bridge to work can be captured at the end of the course. PMScore asks participants anonymously about three components:
Competence gain
How much have participants learned?
Ability to apply
Do they feel able to use what they learned in their own work?
Transfer intention
Do they actually intend to put it into practice?
Together they make up the Transfer Effectiveness Score (TES) from 0 to 100. Ability to apply and transfer intention show whether the training prepared the 70. PMScore also captures the environment, such as support from the manager, in other words the 20. That way you see whether weak transfer is due to the training or to the conditions afterwards.
How such metrics feed into steering learning and development is shown in the post Training controlling: steering learning and development with metrics that show transfer.
What to take away
- Treat 70-20-10 as a rule of thumb, not a measured distribution.
- Do not cut training by pointing to the ten percent; check whether it sets learning on the job in motion.
- Plan transfer tasks and conversations with the manager as part of every training.
- Measure at the end of the course whether participants intend to apply what they learned and feel able to.
See whether your trainings set transfer in motion?
Tell us how you connect formal learning and learning on the job today. In a short conversation we show you how the TES reveals whether your trainings build the bridge to work.
Sources
- Baldwin, T. T., & Ford, J. K. (1988). Transfer of training: A review and directions for future research. Personnel Psychology, 41(1), 63-105.
- Clardy, A. (2018). 70-20-10 and the dominance of informal learning: A fact in search of evidence. Human Resource Development Review, 17(2), 153-178.
- Lombardo, M. M., & Eichinger, R. W. (1996). The Career Architect Development Planner. Minneapolis: Lominger.
- McCall, M. W., Jr., Lombardo, M. M., & Morrison, A. M. (1988). The Lessons of Experience: How Successful Executives Develop on the Job. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.